I am currently in the market for a new anchor for my Westsail 32.  What do you all recommend.

My .02 is to stay with the tried and true... CQR, Bruce, Danforth/Fortress, etc. and not cheaper imitations.  It's not just looking alike that matters. It's how and what they're made of.

The type needed is determined by what type of holding ground you will likely encounter (sand, mud, rock, etc.).  I always say 'When in Rome...'. You might look around your marina, see what common type others are using.

For my Caribbean based W32 (mostly sand or mud) I have a 45# CQR on 150' 3/8 HT chain and a 35# CQR with 20' 3/8" chain and 150' of 3/4' three strand nylon rode up front.

I also have a 35# Bruce on about 10' of 3/8" chain and 100' of 3/4" rode stowed as backup in the lazarette.

I also had a 'throwaway' 20# Danforth (yet to be replaced) I lost trying to kedge off a car sized boulder that rolled off a seawall.

My personal philosophy is don't skimp.  Anchors are like brakes on a car. You can never have too much or too heavy ground tackle. Plan for the worst and hope for the best. The only limiting factor is what you can handle.  Even so, I'd have a 100# fisherman on chain if I knew how I could stow it so it would be readily available. I would much rather lose an anchor for whatever reason than the boat.

we use a 45 lb. delta with 100 ft. 3/8ths high test chain and 200 ft line.

1 - 35# CQR & 300' of chain

1 - 35# CQR & 50' chain + 200' rode

1 - 20# fluke with 200' rode 

I would suggest finding a place for the chain as low as possible and a way to feed it up into the locker when you want to use it. Perhaps somewhere center to aft would be ideal. The storage locker is well above the waterline and 300' of chain throws off the balance quite a bit , not to mention it being forward heavy. I was lucky to have an old black-water tank that was never used under the forward double berth with a deck plate fitting so I keep it down there. 

If I had to start over again I would do a 45 #'er rocna or vulcan with 300' of new chain for my biggest tackle. Then the CQR for my second chain. I like the fluke for times when a single point may not hold, like on a rocky shore.